SALES TAX
Sales Tax Nexus for a Small Seller: Where You Actually Have to Register
Sales tax nexus comes from physical presence or sales volume, and a small seller usually crosses a threshold in only a few states, so check each one.
You shipped an order to a state you have never set foot in, and somebody has told you that you might owe sales tax there. It sounds absurd, and then you look it up and find it is only mostly absurd. The rule that says a business had to be physically present in a state before that state could make it collect tax was thrown out in 2018.
Here is the shape of the answer. A state can require you to collect its sales tax once you have nexus there, which is a legal connection strong enough to justify the obligation. Nexus comes in two flavors now. The old one is physical, and it never went anywhere. The new one is economic, and it turns on how much you sold into that state rather than on whether you were ever in it. You check both, state by state, and you register where either one is satisfied.
None of that means you owe tax in fifty jurisdictions because you have a website. Most small sellers cross a threshold in very few places, and some cross none at all.
Two kinds of nexus, and the old one never went away
Physical nexus is the older test and it is still the easier one to trip. It is satisfied by an office, a store, a warehouse, a plot of land. It is also satisfied by people: an employee working from home in that state, a salesperson who travels there, and in a number of states a contractor doing installation or repair work on your behalf.
The one that surprises sellers is inventory. If your goods sit in a fulfillment warehouse in a state, that is your property in that state, and in most states it creates physical nexus even though you have never chosen that warehouse or seen it. Third party fulfillment networks move stock between locations based on their own logistics. You can acquire nexus in a state overnight without a single decision of your own.
Economic nexus is the newer test. In 2018 the Supreme Court decided South Dakota against Wayfair and abandoned the physical presence requirement it had set in 1992. The South Dakota law it upheld required a remote seller to collect once it had either 100,000 dollars of sales into the state or 200 separate transactions there in the current or previous calendar year. Nearly every state with a sales tax wrote something along those lines afterward.
Along those lines is doing a lot of work in that sentence. The thresholds are not uniform, and they have been revised repeatedly since.
Where the thresholds actually come from
Four things vary between states, and each of them changes your answer.
The dollar amount varies. The transaction count varies, and a number of states have dropped it entirely because it caught tiny sellers shipping many cheap items.
What counts toward the figure varies. Some states measure gross sales, some measure retail sales only, some exclude sales made for resale, and some exclude sales you made through a marketplace that collected on your behalf. Two states with the same dollar threshold can give you two different answers on the same books.
The measurement period varies. Some states look at the previous calendar year. Some look at the previous twelve months on a rolling basis, which means you can cross in March and be out again in September.
And the moment your duty starts varies. In some states you collect on the next transaction after you cross. In others you get until the first day of the following month or quarter to register.
So the honest instruction is the unglamorous one: pull the department of revenue page for the states you actually sell into, and read the threshold and the measurement period as that state wrote them. A national summary table is a starting point and nothing more, because those tables go stale and nobody puts a date on them.
Five states run no statewide sales tax at all, so the question does not arise there. Alaska is the complicated one, because it has no statewide tax but plenty of local ones, and remote sellers deal with a joint local arrangement rather than a state agency.
Marketplaces changed the arithmetic
If you sell through an online marketplace, the marketplace itself is probably collecting and remitting on those orders. States with a sales tax have adopted marketplace facilitator rules that put the obligation on the platform rather than on the seller listing there.
That is a real relief, and it has a sharp edge. Marketplace sales sometimes still count toward your own economic nexus threshold in a state even though the marketplace handled the tax. Cross the threshold on marketplace volume and your own direct sales into that state, small as they are, become taxable and yours to collect. Whether marketplace volume counts is one of the things that varies, which is why sellers who use both a platform and their own website get caught more often than sellers who use one channel.
What registration actually obliges you to do
Registering is the beginning of an ongoing duty, so do not register in a state before you have to. Once you hold a permit, four things follow.
- You collect at the right rate. Most states source an interstate sale to the destination, meaning the buyer's address determines the rate, and the rate is a state portion plus whatever county, city and special district sit under that address. Several states let local jurisdictions administer their own tax separately, so a single state can mean several returns.
- You file returns on the frequency the state assigns you, and you file them in periods where you sold nothing. A zero return is still a return, and missing one produces a penalty for a period in which you made no money.
- You keep exemption certificates. A sale for resale or to an exempt buyer is only exempt if you hold a valid certificate for it. Without the paperwork, an auditor treats the sale as taxable and the tax comes out of your pocket.
- You remit what you collected on time. Sales tax is not your money at any point. You are holding it for the state as its agent.
That last point has teeth that owners underestimate. Most states treat sales tax as a trust fund tax, and most states have a responsible person rule that lets them pursue an owner or officer personally for tax that was collected and not remitted. Forming an LLC does nothing about that.
The traps that cost small sellers the most
Taxability is not universal. Whether a thing is taxable is a separate question from whether you have nexus, and it turns on what you sell and where the buyer is. Services are outside the tax base in many states and inside it in others, and the line moves. Software delivered over a network is taxed in some states and not in others. Shipping charges are taxable in some states, exempt in others, and in a few the answer depends on whether you listed shipping separately on the invoice.
Trailing nexus catches people on the way out. Dropping below a threshold does not always end the obligation immediately. Several states keep you registered and collecting for a defined period afterward, and you close the account formally rather than by walking away.
Back exposure is worth facing early rather than late. If you discover you crossed a threshold two years ago, the liability is the tax you should have collected plus interest and penalty, and it does not improve with age. Most states run a voluntary disclosure program that limits the lookback period for a seller who comes forward before being contacted. That door closes the moment the state writes to you first.
And a permit is not a license. A sales tax permit lets you collect and remit a tax. It grants no permission to operate, which is a different filing at a different agency.
Common questions
do i have to collect sales tax in every state
No. You collect only in states where you have nexus, meaning either a physical connection such as staff or stored inventory, or enough sales volume to cross that state's economic threshold. Most small sellers cross a threshold in a handful of states at most, and five states have no statewide sales tax at all.
does inventory in a fulfillment warehouse create sales tax nexus
In most states it does, because goods you own sitting in a warehouse are your property located in that state. Fulfillment networks move stock between locations on their own schedule, so you can pick up nexus somewhere you never chose. Check which locations are holding your inventory before assuming you are only in one state.
what happens if i should have been collecting sales tax and did not
The liability is the tax you should have collected, plus interest and a penalty, and it keeps growing until it is settled. Most states run a voluntary disclosure program that caps how far back they will look for a seller who comes forward first. That option disappears once the state has contacted you.